If you lend your car to someone and they are involved in an accident, your insurance policy will typically be responsible for covering damages. In New York, auto insurance follows the vehicle, not the driver, meaning that your policy will likely apply first, regardless of who was behind the wheel.
However, liability depends on several factors, including who was at fault, whether the driver had permission, and the details of your insurance policy. In some cases, car owners can be held legally or financially responsible, even if they were not in the vehicle at the time of the accident. A Long Island car accident lawyer can help if your vehicle is involved in an accident.
Understanding Insurance Liability When Lending Your Car
When you lend your car to someone, you are also lending them your insurance coverage. If they cause an accident, your insurance will be the primary source of coverage, paying for damages up to the policy limits. The driver’s personal insurance (if they have any) may serve as secondary coverage if the damages exceed your policy limits.
If the driver was not at fault, the at-fault party’s insurance should cover damages. However, insurance companies may still attempt to dispute claims, leading to delays, denials, or out-of-pocket costs for the vehicle owner.
When You May Be Liable for an Accident Involving Your Car
There are certain circumstances where a car owner could be held responsible for damages caused by another driver.
- Permissive use liability: Your insurance policy applies when you give someone permission to drive your car, making you responsible for any damages they cause.
- Negligent entrustment: If you lend your car to someone you knew was reckless, intoxicated, unlicensed, or otherwise unfit to drive, you may be held liable for the accident.
- Household member use: If a family member or someone living in your household regularly drives your car, your insurance will typically be responsible for any accident they cause.
- Employer liability: If an employee is driving your car for work-related purposes, you could be held responsible under New York’s vicarious liability laws.
Situations Where You May Not Be Liable
There are also scenarios where you would not be responsible for an accident caused by someone driving your car.
- Unauthorized use: If someone took your car without permission and caused an accident, your insurance company may deny coverage and shift liability to the unauthorized driver.
- Excluded driver: If you specifically excluded someone from your insurance policy and they caused an accident while driving your car, your insurer may not cover the damages.
- Employer liability coverage: If the driver was using your car for work under an employer’s direction, the employer’s commercial insurance may be responsible.
- Fraudulent or staged accidents: If an accident is determined to be fraudulent, insurance providers may deny coverage and conduct further investigations.
Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today
The Financial Impact of Lending Your Car
If you lend your car to someone and they get in an accident, even if you are not held legally liable for an accident, you can still have financial consequences.
- Insurance premium increases: If your policy pays for damages, your insurance rates may go up, even if you were not driving.
- Deductible payments: If the claim involves your insurance, you may be required to pay a deductible before coverage applies.
- Out-of-pocket expenses: If damages exceed your policy limits, you may be responsible for covering the remaining costs.
- Loss of vehicle access: If your car is damaged or totaled, you may be without a vehicle while waiting for repairs or compensation.
Can You Recover Damages if Your Insurance Pays for the Accident?
If your insurance company pays for damages after someone you lent your car to causes an accident, you may still have legal options to recover those costs. This process is known as subrogation, where your insurance provider seeks reimbursement from the at-fault driver or their insurance.
- If the driver you lent your car to was not at fault: Your insurance company may pursue a claim against the responsible party’s insurer to recover what they paid out on your behalf. If successful, this may prevent your insurance rates from increasing.
- If the driver you lent your car to was at fault: Your insurer typically absorbs the cost up to your policy limits, but if the damages exceed your coverage, the at-fault driver may be personally responsible for the remaining expenses.
- If your car was taken without permission: If your insurance initially covers damages, they may later seek repayment from the unauthorized driver or any applicable third-party insurance.
Understanding subrogation is important because it affects whether your insurance rates increase and determines whether you can recover costs from another driver or their insurer. In some cases, working with a Long Island car accident attorney can help ensure you are not unfairly held responsible for damages beyond your policy coverage.
Speak With a Long Island Car Accident Attorney
Lending your car to someone may seem harmless, but it carries potential legal and financial risks. If the driver causes an accident, your insurance will likely be responsible, and in some cases, you could face legal liability.
If you are dealing with an insurance dispute, liability claim, or financial concerns after an accident involving your vehicle, Levine And Wiss can help. Our experienced Long Island car accident attorneys can review your case, explain your options, and work to protect your rights.
Contact Levine And Wiss today for a free consultation and let us help you better understand New York’s vehicle liability laws.
